Wednesday, January 8, 2014

Congmen wield the broom in Patna, but recovery would be a long haul

Patna: 17 January, the day the Congress is expected to announce a drastic organisational overhaul, is likely to hold surprises for the party workers and leaders alike. However, many among them already anticipate that the changes would be loaded with the 'back to basics' message from party vice president Rahul Gandhi. It would mean reconnecting with people and be visible at the grassroots level. Rahul may not have made public his plan of action yet, but the Congressmen in Bihar are out to show him that they are up to it and are not short of ideas. They have started hitting the streets with brooms and are busy cleaning up drains in several localities in Patna along with carrying other public contact programmes.

AFP image.

AFP image.

Hundreds of Congressmen armed with broomsticks, baskets, spades and other garbage-cleaning tools get into action on Sundays and clean garbage strewn around localities. While returning, they sprinkle bleaching power to contain the stench emanating from the garbage dumped along the road. "We will be carrying out this drive every Sunday in different localities of the state capital to keep Patna clean as also to make the state government realise their accountability towards the people," said state Congress president Ashok Chaudhary. The party is planning to take its drive across the state soon.

The locals are amused by the sudden spurt of activity from a party which all these years did little beyond holding dharnas, taking out prabhat pheris, submitting memoranda to officials and issuing press statements now and then. However, the party, chastened by the Delhi assembly poll experience and driven to desperation by its hopelessness on home turf, appear dead serious. It has been out of power in the state for close to three decades now and if it does not perform well in the 2014 Lok Sabha polls and the assembly elections in 2015, it would be as good as dead as a political outfit.

The Congress has been performing abysmally in the recent years but the past few elections have proved particularly disastrous for the grand old party. In 2009, after its alliance with the RJD-LJP combine crashed, the Congress fielded its candidates in all 40 LS seats in Bihar, but it ended up winning only two seats—Sasaram, represented by Lok Sabha Speaker Meira Kumar, and Kishanganj, represented by Mohammad Asrarul Haque. It put up an even worse performance during the assembly polls of 2010, winning a miserable four seats out of the total 243 it contested. In the assembly elections of 2005 - there were two elections, one in February, and the other in November, as no party or alliance secured absolute majority - it had bagged 10 and nine seats respectively.

The irony is hard to miss. This is the party which has ruled Bihar for the longest period - not in the continuous sense - since independence. Of the total 22 chief ministers Bihar have had so far, 17 have been from the Congress, indicating the popularity it once enjoyed among the voters.

What is said to have led to the 'slow death' of the party in Bihar was the month-long 1989 Bhagalpur riots which left more than 1,000 people (around 900 of which were Muslims) killed and another 50,000 people displaced. The riots, considered the worst Hindu-Muslim riots in the country after Independence then, started in October 1989 and affected Bhagalpur city and 250 adjoining villages. The Congress government was widely blamed for mishandling the incident and failing to tackle it with firm hands. The result: the Muslims, who once were the traditional voters of the party, began drifting away and soon switched over to the Lalu Prasad's party which came to power in March 1990. In power, Lalu did not allow any major riots to take place in the state. Although a few broke out, Lalu himself camped at the trouble site until the situation was brought under control.

Of late, the Congress leadership has formally apologised to the Muslims for the Bhagalpur riots but the latter is yet to repose faith in the party.

"The party can't gain simply by paying lip service; it will have to show it really means business. The new generations (of Muslims) are no fools. They can't be scared away simply by raising the fear of Narendra Modi," commented a political expert wishing not to be quoted. According to him, the Muslims, of late, have been seen giving more weightage to development and governance than simply acting on sentiments, and also, they look slowly accepting Modi, though hesitatingly.

Veteran journalist MJ Akbar threw more light on the 'fast changing trend' in the country in his speech on "the past and future of Hindu-Muslim relations" he delivered here recently as part of KN Sahay Memorial lecture when he said Narendra Modi's inner voice had surfaced during his October rally at Patna's Gandhi Maidan.

"Crisis is the period when all sorts of preparations for speech turn to be of little help. During the rally, Modi spelt himself out when he appealed to the people of both the communities to together fight poverty, rather than fighting against each other," Akbar said.

Can the Congress' belated realisation of its irrelevance in Bihar change its fortune for the better? There's no clear answer, but there's little doubt that reviving itself would be at least a decade-long effort.


French group Lactalis acquires Hyderabad-based Tirumala Milk

French dairy group Groupe Lactalis SA has acquired a 100 percent stake in India's Tirumala Milk Products Pvt Ltd, in which private equity firm Carlyle Group held a 20 percent stake, the companies said on Wednesday.

According to a person close to the development said the deal is expected to close once necessary approvals are in place. The deal is reportedly valued at $ 275 million ( Rs 1,750 crore).

Representative Image only. Reuters

Representative Image only. Reuters

Danda Brahmanandam, Tirumala's founder and managing director who along with his three partners owns 76 percent stake in the company was not available for comment. Carlye owns rest of the stake percent.

An email sent to Lactalis was not answered till filing this report. Calls made to Lactalis spokesperson Michel NALET were not answered.

Carlyle, the world's second-biggest buyout firm, invested $22 million in the Indian company in 2010.

Tirumala Milk has achieved a turnover of Rs 1424 crore during the last financial year. Tirumala Milk Products, established in 1998, manufactures a wide range of dairy products including milk in sachets, sweets, flavored milk, curd, Milk Powder, Butter, Ghee, Butter oil, and Ice cream.

According to a report in the Economic Times, Tirumala Milk is the second largest milk supplier in south India. Its processing units across Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu have a cumulative capacity of 1.2 million litres a day.

Barclays was financial adviser to Tirumala, while Rothschild was financial adviser to Lactalis.

The deal is likely to help Lactalis reduce its reliance on Europe, where it gets 60 percent of its revenue.

India  is the world's third-largest producer of liquid cow's milk, behind the European Union and US.

A report by the Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India sees the dairy industry in India reaching Rs 5 lakh crore in turnover by 2015.

With inputs from Agencies

 


Arvind Kejriwal announces helpline to trap corrupt govt employees

New Delhi: Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal Wednesday announced a helpline which he said will help trap government employees who demand bribes.

Kejriwal told the media that anyone who is asked to pay a bribe by any official in the capital should seek help on 2735 7169.

Arvind Kejriwal. Reuters

Arvind Kejriwal. Reuters

"This is a helpline number, not a complaint number," he said.

Once the details of the complainant is taken down, the anti-corruption wing of the Delhi administration will explain how to do a sting operation vis-a-vis the corrupt using the recording device of one's mobile phone.

"The idea is to inject fear among bribe seekers," Kejriwal said. "Now an officer demanding bribe won't know if you are recording him on your mobile phone or not."

The vigilance department has deployed a sufficient number of employees for this task, the chief minister said.

If necessary, Delhi Police personnel would also chip in, he added.

"Every citizen is now an anti-corruption crusader (in Delhi)," he said.

The helpline would function from 8 am to 10 pm

Kejriwal had announced after taking oath Dec 28 that he would announce a helpline soon to trap bribe takers.

He said the project got delayed as he found the anti-corruption department was badly understaffed.

IANS


Arvind Kejriwal announce helpline to trap corrupt govt employees

New Delhi: Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal Wednesday announced a helpline which he said will help trap government employees who demand bribes.

Kejriwal told the media that anyone who is asked to pay a bribe by any official in the capital should seek help on 2735 7169.

Arvind Kejriwal. Reuters

Arvind Kejriwal. Reuters

"This is a helpline number, not a complaint number," he said.

Once the details of the complainant is taken down, the anti-corruption wing of the Delhi administration will explain how to do a sting operation vis-a-vis the corrupt using the recording device of one's mobile phone.

"The idea is to inject fear among bribe seekers," Kejriwal said. "Now an officer demanding bribe won't know if you are recording him on your mobile phone or not."

The vigilance department has deployed a sufficient number of employees for this task, the chief minister said.

If necessary, Delhi Police personnel would also chip in, he added.

"Every citizen is now an anti-corruption crusader (in Delhi)," he said.

The helpline would function from 8 am to 10 pm

Kejriwal had announced after taking oath Dec 28 that he would announce a helpline soon to trap bribe takers.

He said the project got delayed as he found the anti-corruption department was badly understaffed.

IANS


Handling AAP office attack needs to go beyond mere lip service

Protest rallies in India aren't uncommon. A call for a debate on any issue invariably sparks off a protest rally - usually a veiled excuse for violence - as well. The violent protest rally outside the AAP office in Ghaziabad then, hardly comes as a surprise given the highly charged political atmosphere in which Prashant Bhushan commented on Kashmir.

Bhushan is no stranger to such attacks for his opinions on Kashmir. He was audaciously attacked in his chambers in 2011 while giving an interview to a television channel over his comments over having a referendum in the state.

The group that attacked him then, claimed responsibility on their Facebook page saying, "We hit Prashant Bhushan hard in his chamber in Supreme Court. If u will try to break my nation, I will break ur heads."

Today's protest at the AAP office was for the same reason but was carried out by a different group.  Taking the place of the Bhagat Singh Kranti Sena is the Hindu Raksha Sena, and they seem to not only have more man power than their esteemed predecessors, but also believe in spreading the blame around.

The attack on the AAP office

The attack on the AAP office

Pinky Choudhary, the national convenor of the group, had a simple reason for the decision to attack an office where even women and children were reportedly milling around.

"We today staged a protest against AAP's stand on Kashmir. AAP's leader Prashant Bhushan's remark on Kashmir is very sad for Hindus due to which we have staged protest outside party office," he said.

Choudhary has been arrested for his role in the attack, but this may actually be a small price he is paying in the longer run. This may in fact herald the start of a possibly lucrative and healthy political career.

Take his predecessor, who attacked Bhushan. That worthy individual has since moved on to making t-shirts glorifying the BJP's Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi and may gradually even make a surreptitious entry into mainstream politics.

But this is not an isolated case.

Most Indian political parties have a long history of not shunning candidates with criminal records, and definitely not those who are accused of what are largely considered to be 'wink and nod' minor offences like violent protest. In fact, affidavits submitted by current MLAs and MPs show that as many as 19 percent of them have criminal records.

When it comes to MPs in the Lok Sabha the number is higher, at 30 percent. An Association for Democratic Rights report noted that the probability was high that a candidate with a criminal record has a higher chance of winning polls than a clean candidate. This however only considers elected representatives to higher legislative bodies and does not include those elected to smaller bodies like municipalities and panchayats.

In the instance of the attack on AAP, the Congress could point fingers at the BJP, but their record is not much better. The argument of politically motivated cases falls flat when it is a case of inciting mob violence of the kind witnessed today, but this is often a good enough argument for a party to welcome such a candidate into its fold.  The onus will continue to lie on political parties to ensure that they only encourage clean representatives to contest on their tickets and shun those who don't meet the criteria.

The BJP and AAP are already engaged in a war of words that will go little beyond a headline or two. In a contentious national election where probity, performance and clean politics has come to the fore, there will be no better time for political parties to send out a clear message. And it will be up to the national parties, to show that they are capable of doing more than paying lip service to the ideas that have gained popularity thanks to the AAP.

The AAP office will be repaired, the Hindu Raksha Dal will wait for its next target and as it stands, politics will, unfortunately, continue as usual. Unless Pinky Choudhury pays a higher price in his fledgling political career than just a few hours in jail, it will just be business as usual. 


Rajasthan: Raje asks officials to ensure 24-hr domestic power supply

Jaipur: Rajasthan Chief Minister Vasundhara Raje today asked officials to ensure round-the-clock domestic power supply and six-and-a-half hour uninterrupted electricity supply to farmers.

Speaking at the inaugural session of two-day Collectors and SPs conference here, the Chief Minister also directed them to effectively monitor water projects and ensure proper arrangements in government hospitals and schools.

Vasundhara Raje. AFP

Vasundhara Raje. AFP

Raje presented the vision of the state government and asked the officers to make collective efforts for accelerating growth and development in the state.

She asked Collectors to effectively implement a 60-day action plan of the state government to improve delivery of public services and do a weekly review to ensure proper monitoring.

In her address, she laid emphasis on putting a mechanism in place where voices of all sections are heard and their grievances are redressed, and opinion of all sections including Dalits and Minorities, are incorporated in the decision-making process of the government.

Members of the council of ministers, Chief Secretary, all Additional CS, Principal Secretaries, specially invited officials and Collectors, Divisional Commissioners participated in the conference.

Police officials will participate with Collectors on the second day of the conference tomorrow.

PTI


Left to launch nationwide protest next week on price rise issue

New Delhi: Left parties on Wednesday decided to carry out a nationwide agitation from next week to protest the "exorbitant" rise in prices of essential items and petro products and demanded a universal public distribution system.

Reuters

Reuters

The parties expressed serious concern at "the crushing burden of price rise which is affecting all sections of the people" and charged the UPA government with "adding fuel to the fire by continuously increasing the prices of petrol, diesel, LPG and CNG".

The decision for the agitation was taken at a meeting of top CPI(M), CPI, All India Forward Bloc and RSP leaders here.

Maintaining that there was "no respite in the upward spiral of prices of food items and essential commodities with food inflation reaching a record high of 20 per cent", they asked all their state units to carry out the anti-price rise agitation between January 15-31.

In a joint statement issued after the meeting, the Left leaders said their agitation would focus on several demands, including stoppage of hikes in prices of petroleum products and restoration of the administrative price mechanism.

They would also demand steps to end hoarding and speculation of essential commodities and conducting of de-hoarding campaign in all states, besides opposing any linkage between Aadhar and the delivery of services and subsidies to the people.

Apart from seeking universal public distribution system, the Left leaders also opposed privatisation of basic services and sought conduct audit of those private companies utilising public resources and delivering basic services.

The meeting was attended by veteran CPI leader A B Bardhan, general secretaries of CPI(M) Prakash Karat, CPI's S Sudhakar Reddy and Forward Bloc's Debabrata Biswas, senior CPI(M) leader Sitaram Yechury and RSP leader Abani Roy.

PTI


Does AAP’s all-woman commando force spell trouble ahead in Delhi?

When AAP launched its election manifesto ahead of the Delhi Assembly polls, one of the more headline grabbing initiatives outlined in the document (along with free water and cheap electricity) was its innovative and somewhat outlandish concept of a special 'commando' force to protect women in the city.

Women's safety is one of the most talked about issues in Delhi. Historically considered an 'unsafe city' for its women, the issue however was catapulted into the spotlight with the brutal 16 December gangrape. The public anger and outcry that followed the incident is also seen as one of the key issues that ultimately led to the downfall of Kejriwal's predecessor, Sheila Dikshit. With the subject so top of mind in the city so close to elections, it was unsurprising that AAP focused on the issue so closely. However to say that many people were not expecting a commando force is a safe bet.

Reuters

Reuters

The initiative was greeted with some trepidation as soon as it was announced.

"Former bureaucrats and army personnel often have no clue what the needs of women are. The question is what kind of perspective will these Citizen Security Forces have when it comes to women's safety. If it is the dominant, patriarchal values, then it will be of no use," said All India Progressive Women's Association Secretary, Kavita Krishnan in an interview with Firstpost. She also pointed out that the point of armed vigilantes was something that people needed to be concerned about.

Concerns notwithstanding however, AAP has begun setting the foundation for the commando force. At the helm of this effort is Delhi's newly appointed women and child welfare minister Rakhi Birla. According to this report in the Times of India, Birla has said that the initiative will begin with an all women's commando force.

"We are starting with an all-women commando force. Several ex-armymen and martial art instructors have been roped in to train women. Interestingly, more than men, women are coming forward to get trained, which is a positive sign. They will be trained in Taekwondo and then deployed on several stretches at night," she told the newspaper.

Birla has not provided much more information about the commando force, like how they plan to deal with perpetrators of harassment and how women in distress can contact them. And it is this sort of lofty vagueness about the force has fueled concerns that it could rapidly deteriorate into an armed vigilante group operating outside the powers of the law.

As RTI activist Shekhar Singh earlier pointed out to Firstpost, "The Commando forces aspect is bit worrying. The fear is that sometimes these armed forces might well be the worst perpetrators of crimes against women. From a sociological perspective, we've always seen that when there is any kind of violence, the other party always ups the ante and the cycle of violence gets worse".

The idea behind empowering the people to be able to look after themselves and their loved ones is a compelling idea, but has the potential to backfire.

As put across so powerfully by Firstpost columnist Seetha Parthasarathy:

Delhi needs an active and vigilant citizenry; but this should not become an aggressive vigilante mode, which is susceptible to misuse. The initial lot of AAP volunteers may be an idealistic bunch who will not misuse their powers, but can AAP stand guarantee for each and every volunteer, especially those flocking to it in droves after it formed the government?


Do you want to kill me, Kejriwal asks those who attacked AAP office

New Delhi: Hours after the attack this morning on the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) headquarters in Kaushambi, Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal questioned the miscreants' motive and wondered whether they wanted to kill him and Prashant Bhushan because of the latter's remarks on Kashmir.

"Let us assume that Prashant Bhushan indeed said something objectionable, so what do they want? Do they want to kill Prashantji?"

"We have cleared the stand of our party and (Bhushan) has also said many times that his opinion was misinterpreted. He has even stated that he doesn't want a referendum," Kejriwal said, adding, "Do they also want to kill me?"

Reiterating his stand on Kashmir, Kejriwal said it was an integral part of India and nobody could separate it from the country.

"Army deployment in various parts of the country is a matter of internal security assessment, which is done by the government. The sentiments of local people should be respected in such decisions," he said, adding that the issue cannot be solved by a referendum.

Kejriwal has questioned the rationale behind the attack. PTI

Kejriwal has questioned the rationale behind the attack. PTI

He further added that, "No god can create such a 'sena' (army) that attacks the offices and houses of people. It is against the principles of Lord Rama. I am also a Hindu."

Activists of right-wing group Hindu Raksha Dal today attacked and vandalised the AAP headquarters to protest against Bhushan's remarks concerning a referendum in Kashmir.

Around 40 activists broke flower pots kept outside the AAP office and tore up posters. Some glass doors were also smashed in the attack.

PTI


Not hostile to US, steps taken based on reciprocity: Khurshid

New Delhi: India said Wednesday that its retaliatory measures against the US embassy and consulates in India over the handcuffing and strip-search of an envoy are "not hostile" but based on reciprocity.

External Affairs Minister Salman Khurshid to a question on the latest measures against the US, said: "We're not hostile, this is an arrangement based on reciprocity."

In its latest step, India has told the US that the commercial activities being undertaken from inside the US embassy premises in Delhi should be stopped by 16 January and that all US diplomatic vehicles found flouting rules will also attract penalties.

Khurshid said the US has said that they are following their rules in the matter of Indian diplomat Devyani Khobragade, who was arrested on 12 December in New York for alleged visa fraud and underpaying her nanny.

The foreign minister denied any hostility between the two nations. PTI

The foreign minister denied any hostility between the two nations. PTI

"They said they will do what is in their rules... we have indicated that please don't take steps that may harm any agreement between us."

"Our position is reciprocity, which is an evolving process. When we realise we don't have reciprocity on something, we do that (take that step). We're not hostile, this is an arrangement based on reciprocity," he said.

According to government sources, several commercial activities were being undertaken under the aegis of the American Community Support Association (ACSA), including a restaurant/bar, video club, bowling alley, swimming pool, sports field, beauty parlour and gym inside the embassy premises.

"The US has been asked to provide the tax returns filed by it with Indian authorities for the commercial activities which are through ACSA to non-diplomatic persons, including private American citizens and their families," the sources added.

In a related development, US diplomatic vehicles are to also attract penalties for all traffic related offences such as unauthorized parking, not stopping at red light, dangerous driving, the sources added.

"Necessary action against Vehicles with AF (Applied for) number plates is also on the cards," the source added.

The Dec 12 handcuffing and strip-search of Khobragade, India's deputy consul general in New York, caused widespread outrage in India.

She has denied the charges of visa fraud and underpaying her nanny.

India has demanded the US take back all charges against Khobragade and offer an unconditional apology.

India has already withdrawn the airport passes given to US diplomats in India and the special diplomatic identity cards issued to them as part of reciprocal measures after the arrest of Khobragade.

IANS


Asok Kumar Ganguly: Let’s separate the institution from the man

The long mull of Asok Kumar Ganguly has ended.

The retired Supreme Court judge has finally resigned as chairman of the West Bengal Human Rights Commission, dogged by accusations of sexual misconduct. He still insists they are "unfounded and baseless" but his protestations have found few sympathetic ears. His obstinate refusal to step down and hemming and hawing have only brought out more and more lurid details about his alleged misdeeds and tarnished his reputation.

Retd Supreme Court Judge AK Ganguly. PTI

Retd Supreme Court Judge AK Ganguly. PTI

But probably no one is happier about this than Mamata Banerjee who will get to appoint the next head in consultation with the leader of the Opposition. As soon as the allegations surfaced, Trinamool MPs were vociferous in demanding Ganguly's resignation. However that does not mean it's because Didi is the champion of the sexual harassed and sexually molested. The family of the girl gang-raped twice in Madhyamgram has complained that Mamata has found no time for them and the police have been more interested in covering their own failings. Trinamool's satisfaction with Ganguly's downfall has nothing to do with any new-found zero-tolerance for sexual harassment. Ganguly and his human rights commission had been a persistent thorn in the side of the government, way more pro-active than the government liked.

It had tried to trip him up over and over again raising questions about a two-day trip to Pakistan in June 2013 to attend a law seminar. It framed a charge against him for an arbitration assignment on behalf of the All India Football Federation.

"I am a victim of conspiracy," Ganguly told The Telegraph after he tendered his resignation, accusing the government of a "hostile approach".

But the truth is Ganguly seems to have done to himself what the state government could not manage – engineer his fall from grace.

However it's important to separate his alleged personal failings from his professional career and not tar both with the same brush. Just as the journalism of Tehelka should be judged separately from the alleged misdeeds of Tarun Tejpal in that elevator in Goa, the record of the West Bengal Human Rights Commission under Asok Kumar Ganguly should not become collateral damage to his alleged physical and verbal overtures to an intern.

When Mamata Banerjee called the farmer Shiladitya Banerjee a Maoist at a public meeting for asking her about fertilizer prices, he was slapped with non-bailable charges and tossed into jail for 14 days. The WBHRC took up his case.

"Shiladitya Chowdhury must be compensated for the loss of dignity and social status at the instance of the honourable chief minister in an open meeting. It cannot be that just because he is a poor farmer, his status and dignity can be trifled with by slapping a wild allegation of being a Maoist/terrorist," wrote the commission.

It asked the government to pay him a compensation of Rs 2 lakh.

After the infamous "Cartoon-gate" episode when Jadavpur University professor Ambikesh Mahapatra was locked up for forwarding a cartoon mocking Mamata and her minister, it was Asok Kumar Ganguly's commission that pulled up the government and demanded it pay Rs 50,000 in compensation.

When Trinamool MP Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar made comments about the character of the Park Street rape survivor, the commission took note of it. The MP apologised. After the Kamduni rape, Mamata Banerjee described some village women who came to her with complaints as "Maoists". The commission asked those residents to come before it and record their fears and concerns. Even Mamata's security personnel found a sympathetic ear within the commission. When an irate Mamata once said her security officer "should be whipped" for making her wait too long for her car at the Kolkata Book Fair, a civil rights complained to the commission which had harsh words for the chief minister.

Clearly, Asok Kumar Ganguly, though appointed to the commission by Mamata Banerjee, was not the chief minister's favourite person.

He had a reputation for uprightness as a Supreme Court judge. During the 2G spectrum case he told the CBI "You have not done anything and (Raja) continues as minister. Is this the way the government functions?" He had said the Constitution Bench decision that upheld the suspension of fundamental rights during the Emergency was "erroneous."

But as a chairman of the Human Rights Commission he proved a little too pro-actively upright for the government. In an earlier interview with The Telegraph he certainly did not endear himself to Didi with his comments about her sonar Bangla.

"Human rights violations are quite rampant in Bengal," he said. "There was a lot of expectation when a new party came to power in the state. I do not know how much of that has been fulfilled. But one thing is clear – the complaints are rising by the day and this reflects the state of human rights here."

The numbers speak for themselves. In 2011-12, 5,456 complaints were filed before the commission. Between 2012-2013 that almost doubled to 9,415. However only 75 recommendations were made by the commission proving it was not exactly trigger-happy.

Ganguly had also said that the commission's recommendations should be made more meaningful so that even if the government disregards them it should be forced "to provide adequate reasons as to why it is not following the recommendations."

The commission's point was simple as it spelled it out in a report. "The honourable CM is a democratically elected popular leader. Even such a leader has to abide by Constitutional norms."

Unfortunately as Asok Kumar Ganguly is discovering to his chagrin, he too is not above the law. Like Caesar's wife, the chairperson of a human rights commission, has to be above suspicion. When the Additional Solicitor General Indira Jaising made public the intern's affidavit about Ganguly's "unwelcome behaviour" she said "now the issue does not just concern her, but the integrity of the institution that Ganguly is heading."

That is important to remember. The institution and the man are not the same though his enemies will use one to attack the other. In Ganguly's hour of disgrace it's worth noting that none of this means his work as the chairman of the West Bengal Human Rights Commission should also be disgraced with him. That record is worth defending even if Ganguly's personal conduct proves to be indefensible.


Handling AAP office attack needs to go beyond lip service

Protest rallies in India aren't uncommon. A call for a debate on any issue invariably sparks off a protest rally - usually a veiled excuse for violence - as well. The violent protest rally outside the AAP office in Ghaziabad then, hardly comes as a surprise given the highly charged political atmosphere in which Prashant Bhushan commented on Kashmir.

Bhushan is no stranger to such attacks for his opinions on Kashmir. He was audaciously attacked in his chambers in 2011 while giving an interview to a television channel over his comments over having a referendum in the state.

The group that attacked him then, claimed responsibility on their Facebook page saying, "We hit Prashant Bhushan hard in his chamber in Supreme Court. If u will try to break my nation, I will break ur heads."

Today's protest at the AAP office was for the same reason but was carried out by a different group.  Taking the place of the Bhagat Singh Kranti Sena is the Hindu Raksha Sena, and they seem to not only have more man power than their esteemed predecessors, but also believe in spreading the blame around.

The attack on the AAP office

The attack on the AAP office

Pinky Choudhary, the national convenor of the group, had a simple reason for the decision to attack an office where even women and children were reportedly milling around.

"We today staged a protest against AAP's stand on Kashmir. AAP's leader Prashant Bhushan's remark on Kashmir is very sad for Hindus due to which we have staged protest outside party office," he said.

Choudhary has been arrested for his role in the attack, but this may actually be a small price he is paying in the longer run. This may in fact herald the start of a possibly lucrative and healthy political career.

Take his predecessor, who attacked Bhushan. That worthy individual has since moved on to making t-shirts glorifying the BJP's Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi and may gradually even make a surreptitious entry into mainstream politics.

But this is not an isolated case.

Most Indian political parties have a long history of not shunning candidates with criminal records, and definitely not those who are accused of what are largely considered to be 'wink and nod' minor offences like violent protest. In fact, affidavits submitted by current MLAs and MPs show that as many as 19 percent of them have criminal records.

When it comes to MPs in the Lok Sabha the number is higher, at 30 percent. An Association for Democratic Rights report noted that the probability was high that a candidate with a criminal record has a higher chance of winning polls than a clean candidate. This however only considers elected representatives to higher legislative bodies and does not include those elected to smaller bodies like municipalities and panchayats.

In the instance of the attack on AAP, the Congress could point fingers at the BJP, but their record is not much better. The argument of politically motivated cases falls flat when it is a case of inciting mob violence of the kind witnessed today, but this is often a good enough argument for a party to welcome such a candidate into its fold.  The onus will continue to lie on political parties to ensure that they only encourage clean representatives to contest on their tickets and shun those who don't meet the criteria.

The BJP and AAP are already engaged in a war of words that will go little beyond a headline or two. In a contentious national election where probity, performance and clean politics has come to the fore, there will be no better time for political parties to send out a clear message. And it will be up to the national parties, to show that they are capable of doing more than paying lip service to the ideas that have gained popularity thanks to the AAP.

The AAP office will be repaired, the Hindu Raksha Dal will wait for its next target and as it stands, politics will, unfortunately, continue as usual. Unless Pinky Choudhury pays a higher price in his fledgling political career than just a few hours in jail, it will just be business as usual. 


Rahul-Priyanka won’t pose threat to Narendra Modi: Shivraj Chouhan

Bhopal: Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan today said Congress Vice President Rahul Gandhi or his sister Priyanka are unlikely to pose any challenge to BJP's Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi in the forthcoming Lok Sabha elections.

"There is no challenge. The people of the country have made up their mind and this has become clear in many programmes being organised (for Modi) in the country," he told reporters at the state BJP office here.

Shivraj Singh Chouhan. AFP

Shivraj Singh Chouhan. AFP

The CM was answering a queries on whether the duo be able to put up a challenge to Modi after Priyanka joined Rahul Gandhi to fine-tune the campaign strategy of the party.

Chouhan said that Madhya Pradesh would strive to give its best for bringing BJP back to power at the Centre and also towards making Modi the Prime Minister.

He said the state unit's contribution towards realising these two goals should be distinct from others.

Earlier, addressing the concluding session of the Madhya Pradesh BJP's two-day-long state executive meeting, Chouhan urged party leaders to focus on 'Mission-29' by winning all the 29 Lok Sabha seats in the state.

PTI


Defamation row: Patkar, NGO chief to settle for compromise

New Delhi: A Delhi court on Wednesday asked Narmada Bachao Andolan activist Medha Patkar and the head of an Ahmedabad-based NGO to inform it by 25 March whether the two can compromise and withdraw the defamation cases which they have lodged against each other.

Activist Medha Patkar.

Activist Medha Patkar.

Metropolitan Magistrate Deepak Wason has asked Patkar and VK Saxena, president of the NGO, National Council for Civil Liberties (NCCL), to settle their differences and withdraw the defamation cases. Wason is hearing three separate cases lodged by Patkar and Saxena against each other.

"It is submitted by the counsel that there are chances of compromise with the parties. Put up for compromise if any... on March 25," the court said, allowing Saxena's plea for exemption for the day after his flight was cancelled due to bad weather.

Saxena's absence was opposed by Patkar and her counsel VK Ohri, who requested the court to impose costs on the former as she herself had been fined for her non appearance in the case.

"A fine was imposed on me when I was on an indefinite hunger strike for some good cause," Patkar told the court, adding that the fine slapped on her had been a huge sum for her to pay.

The court, however, said that it would not be fair to do so and suggested that they instead settle their cases and withdraw them. To which Patkar said that if Saxena was willing, she was ready to settle for a compromise.

Advocate Mahipal Ahluwalia and Subhashis R Soren, counsels for Saxena, said that they needed to take instructions from their client.

But Saxena's counsels pointed out that since Patkar had first filed the case against their client, if she withdrew and settled the matter, he would do so too.

However, the judge said, "Whether you do first or her. No one will become small, if they withdrew the case first."

Meanwhile, Patkar told the judge that Saxena wanted her to withdraw cases against him lodged in Ahmedabad, which she said she cannot do.

The judge said, "I am only concerned with my cases".

PTI


Handling attack on AAP office needs to go beyond lip service

Protest rallies in India aren't uncommon. A call for a debate on any issue invariably sparks off a protest rally - usually a veiled excuse for violence - as well. The violent protest rally outside the AAP office in Ghaziabad then, hardly comes as a surprise given the highly charged political atmosphere in which Prashant Bhushan commented on Kashmir.

Bhushan is no stranger to such attacks for his opinions on Kashmir. He was audaciously attacked in his chambers in 2011 while giving an interview to a television channel over his comments over having a referendum in the state.

The group that attacked him then, claimed responsibility on their Facebook page saying, "We hit Prashant Bhushan hard in his chamber in Supreme Court. If u will try to break my nation, I will break ur heads."

Today's protest at the AAP office was for the same reason but was carried out by a different group.  Taking the place of the Bhagat Singh Kranti Sena is the Hindu Raksha Sena, and they seem to not only have more man power than their esteemed predecessors, but also believe in spreading the blame around.

The attack on the AAP office

The attack on the AAP office

Pinky Choudhary, the national convenor of the group, had a simple reason for the decision to attack an office where even women and children were reportedly milling around.

"We today staged a protest against AAP's stand on Kashmir. AAP's leader Prashant Bhushan's remark on Kashmir is very sad for Hindus due to which we have staged protest outside party office," he said.

Choudhary has been arrested for his role in the attack, but this may actually be a small price he is paying in the longer run. This may in fact herald the start of a possibly lucrative and healthy political career.

Take his predecessor, who attacked Bhushan. That worthy individual has since moved on to making t-shirts glorifying the BJP's Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi and may gradually even make a surreptitious entry into mainstream politics.

But this is not an isolated case.

Most Indian political parties have a long history of not shunning candidates with criminal records, and definitely not those who are accused of what are largely considered to be 'wink and nod' minor offences like violent protest. In fact, affidavits submitted by current MLAs and MPs show that as many as 19 percent of them have criminal records.

When it comes to MPs in the Lok Sabha the number is higher, at 30 percent. An Association for Democratic Rights report noted that the probability was high that a candidate with a criminal record has a higher chance of winning polls than a clean candidate. This however only considers elected representatives to higher legislative bodies and does not include those elected to smaller bodies like municipalities and panchayats.

In the instance of the attack on AAP, the Congress could point fingers at the BJP, but their record is not much better. The argument of politically motivated cases falls flat when it is a case of inciting mob violence of the kind witnessed today, but this is often a good enough argument for a party to welcome such a candidate into its fold.  The onus will continue to lie on political parties to ensure that they only encourage clean representatives to contest on their tickets and shun those who don't meet the criteria.

The BJP and AAP are already engaged in a war of words that will go little beyond a headline or two. In a contentious national election where probity, performance and clean politics has come to the fore, there will be no better time for political parties to send out a clear message. And it will be up to the national parties, to show that they are capable of doing more than paying lip service to the ideas that have gained popularity thanks to the AAP.

The AAP office will be repaired, the Hindu Raksha Dal will wait for its next target and as it stands, politics will, unfortunately, continue as usual. Unless Pinky Choudhury pays a higher price in his fledgling political career than just a few hours in jail, it will just be business as usual. 


Dancer-activist Mallika Sarabhai to join Aam Aadmi Party

Ahmedabad: Noted danseuse Mallika Sarabhai will be joining the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) today, sources close to her today said.

"Mallika Sarabhai will be joining the AAP later in the day by going to their office in the city," they told PTI.

Mallika Sarabhai. Pic courtesy IBNLive

Mallika Sarabhai. Pic courtesy IBNLive

"She will be joining the party not as a politician but as a citizen of the country," they said.

In 2009, Sarabhai fought elections as an Independent candidate against BJP veteran L K Advani from the Gandhinagar constituency but had lost.

She has been constantly taking up the issue of oppressed and victims of the 2002 riots.

The AAP led by Arvind Kejriwal made a spectacular debut in the recent Delhi Assembly elections bagging 28 seats.

PTI


Kejriwal, Modi big megalomaniacs with dictatorial streak: Digvijaya

Bhopal: In an apparent dig at Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal's brand of citizen activism, Congress General Secretary Digvijaya Singh on Wednesday said emergence of AAP on the national scene was testimony to the fact that issues cannot be resolved on streets but only through democratic ways.

Congress General Secretary Digvijaya Singh. PTI

Congress General Secretary Digvijaya Singh. PTI

"It is much better if someone instead of shouting on the streets takes to politics, forms a party and enters assembly or Parliament," Digvijaya told reporters in Bhopal.

"Everyone should realise that bills are passed and laws enacted only in Parliament and not on Ramlila Maidan," he said without elaborating further.

He, however, said that both Kejriwal and BJP Prime Ministerial nominee Narendra Modi were "big megalomaniacs with a strong dictatorial streak."

"I am saying this as I know that both of them like to listen only to their voices and do not pay heed to anyone else," Digvijaya said.

"It was because of this streak that Kejriwal drove away many people including Narmada Bachao Andolan leader Medha Patkar," he added.

Asked if Congress Vice President Rahul Gandhi would be named as the party's Prime Ministerial nominee on January 17, he said, "Personally, I am strongly opposed to naming Prime Ministers or Chief Ministers before the polls."

About Priyanka attending a Congress meeting in New Delhi on Tuesday, Digvijaya said that she was looking after the party's media work for the 2014 Lok Sabha elections.

"She also takes a keen interest in party affairs in Raebareli and Amethi", he said.

On Congress' defeat in the 25 November assembly elections in Madhya Pradesh, he conceded that the macro-management of the BJP was much better than that of his party in the state.

Hitting out at the ruling BJP, he said, "may be people of Madhya Pradesh wanted a government which was involved in scams and which said one thing and did the other."

What the government said and did was evident from the way in which it decided to allow country liquor shops in big villages to sell Indian Made Foreign Liquor, Digvijaya said.

This would allow 200-250 country liquor shops to sell Indian Made Foreign Liquor, he said.

The Congress General Secretary said that the decision came after Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan had announced that no new liquor shops would be opened in the state.

Singh said when he began his political career long back in 1977 he was in the Congress which was then in the Opposition in Madhya Pradesh.

He said that having a stint in the Opposition is always a good thing for any legislator who is elected for the first time.

The Congress General Secretary reiterated his demand for a CBI probe into the scam in the Madhya Pradesh Professional Examination Board (PEB).

Digvijaya said that when he was Chief Minister, he had got the rules amended to ensure that only those who passed X or XII from MP could appear in examinations conducted by the PEB.

He said that these rules were amended after the BJP came to power and now students from Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and Bihar were appearing in examinations conducted by the State PEB.

He said that because of this, many students in Madhya Pradesh had suffered a lot.

Digvijaya said he did not understand why the state government was afraid of a CBI investigation into the PEB scam.

He said that during his tenure, he had never been shy of recommending a CBI probe into any matter.

The Congress General Secretary said that he had filed contempt suits against Uma Bharti, Sunderlal Patwa and Vikram Verma who had charged him with corruption.

Digvijaya also dared the Chief Minister to file a contempt case against him.

PTI


Hindu Rakshak head Bhupendra Tomar held for AAP office attack

Bhupendra Tomar alias Pinky Chaudhary, the national convenor of the Hindu Raksha Dal, accused of leading the mob attack on the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) office in this Uttar Pradesh town, bordering the national capital, surrendered to police.

Tomar is believed to have led the protests and vandalisation at the AAP office in Kaushambi in Ghaziabad Wednesday. He surrendered at the Indirapuram police station.

"We are against the statement made by Prashant Bhushan (on army deployment in the Kashmir Valley), and will not tolerate such statements," Tomar told IANS.

"I have committed no crime. The police came to my party office and I surrendered," he told reporters at the police station.

A group of 30-40 people attacked the AAP office in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh and vandalised property today in a reprisal for Aam Aadmi Party leader Prashant Bhushan's statement on holding a referendum on keeping the army in Jammu and Kashmir.

A screengrab from the CCTV footage at the AAP office.

A screengrab from the CCTV footage at the AAP office.

CNN-IBN reported that around 40 persons carrying flags came to the AAP office in Kaushambi in Uttar Pradesh and threw stones at the office while shouting slogans. The protest lasted almost 15 to 20 minutes and property outside the office was damaged as the AAP volunteers in the office had locked themselves in the building.

Uttar Pradesh police officials said that they had rushed additional forces there and were in the process of examining CCTV footage to identify those who were involved in vandalism.

They said no one was injured in the attack. SSP Dharmendra Singh said, "We have identified some people. There were some residents of Ghaziabad and the numbers of their cars have been noted. Action against them will be initiated soon."

He said there was no security at the party office but policemen have now been deployed there and at Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal's residence which is just a kilometre away. He said they will again take up the issue of security with Kejriwal and try to convince him about that.

Earlier, Kejriwal had turned down the security offered to him by Ghaziabad and Delhi Police.

Kejriwal came out strongly against the attack on the party's Kaushambi office saying the attackers can kill him if that solves the Kashmir issue. He said, "If they think by killing me or Prashant Bhushan, the Kashmir issue will get resolved, then they should tell me the place and date when they want to kill me and I'll go."

The group involved in the attack reportedly identified themselves as the Hindu Raksha Dal, and said they had attacked the office on account of Bhushan's statements. "We attacked AAP's office because of Prashant Bhushan's remarks on Kashmir," NDTV quoted a senior functionary of the group as saying.

The Hindu Raksha Dal activists broke flower pots kept outside AAP's office and tore party posters. Some glass doors were also smashed in the attack.

"We today staged a protest against AAP's stand on Kashmir. AAP's leader Prashant Bhushan's remark on Kashmir is very sad for Hindus due to which we have staged protest outside party office," said Pinky Choudhary, national convenor, Hindu Raksha Dal.


Hindu Rakshak chief Pinky Chaudhary held for AAP office attack

Following a mass attack on the Aam Aadmi Party's office in Kaushambi, the Hindu Rakshak Dal chief Pinky Choudhary has been detained.

A group of 30-40 people attacked the AAP office in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh and vandalised property today in a reprisal for Aam Aadmi Party leader Prashant Bhushan's statement on holding a referendum on keeping the army in Jammu and Kashmir.

A screengrab from the CCTV footage at the AAP office.

A screengrab from the CCTV footage at the AAP office.

CNN-IBN reported that around 40 persons carrying flags came to the AAP office in Kaushambi in Uttar Pradesh and threw stones at the office while shouting slogans. The protest lasted almost 15 to 20 minutes and property outside the office was damaged as the AAP volunteers in the office had locked themselves in the building.

Uttar Pradesh police officials said that they had rushed additional forces there and were in the process of examining CCTV footage to identify those who were involved in vandalism.

They said no one was injured in the attack. SSP Dharmendra Singh said, "We have identified some people. There were some residents of Ghaziabad and the numbers of their cars have been noted. Action against them will be initiated soon."

He said there was no security at the party office but policemen have now been deployed there and at Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal's residence which is just a kilometre away. He said they will again take up the issue of security with Kejriwal and try to convince him about that.

Earlier, Kejriwal had turned down the security offered to him by Ghaziabad and Delhi Police.

Kejriwal came out strongly against the attack on the party's Kaushambi office saying the attackers can kill him if that solves the Kashmir issue. He said, "If they think by killing me or Prashant Bhushan, the Kashmir issue will get resolved, then they should tell me the place and date when they want to kill me and I'll go."

The group involved in the attack reportedly identified themselves as the Hindu Raksha Dal, and said they had attacked the office on account of Bhushan's statements. "We attacked AAP's office because of Prashant Bhushan's remarks on Kashmir," NDTV quoted a senior functionary of the group as saying.

The Hindu Raksha Dal activists broke flower pots kept outside AAP's office and tore party posters. Some glass doors were also smashed in the attack.

"We today staged a protest against AAP's stand on Kashmir. AAP's leader Prashant Bhushan's remark on Kashmir is very sad for Hindus due to which we have staged protest outside party office," said Pinky Choudhary, national convenor, Hindu Raksha Dal.


Hindu Rakshak head Pinky Chaudhary held for AAP office attack

Following a mass attack on the Aam Aadmi Party's office in Kaushambi, the Hindu Rakshak Dal chief Pinky Choudhary has been detained.

A group of 30-40 people attacked the AAP office in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh and vandalised property today in a reprisal for Aam Aadmi Party leader Prashant Bhushan's statement on holding a referendum on keeping the army in Jammu and Kashmir.

A screengrab from the CCTV footage at the AAP office.

A screengrab from the CCTV footage at the AAP office.

CNN-IBN reported that around 40 persons carrying flags came to the AAP office in Kaushambi in Uttar Pradesh and threw stones at the office while shouting slogans. The protest lasted almost 15 to 20 minutes and property outside the office was damaged as the AAP volunteers in the office had locked themselves in the building.

Uttar Pradesh police officials said that they had rushed additional forces there and were in the process of examining CCTV footage to identify those who were involved in vandalism.

They said no one was injured in the attack. SSP Dharmendra Singh said, "We have identified some people. There were some residents of Ghaziabad and the numbers of their cars have been noted. Action against them will be initiated soon."

He said there was no security at the party office but policemen have now been deployed there and at Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal's residence which is just a kilometre away. He said they will again take up the issue of security with Kejriwal and try to convince him about that.

Earlier, Kejriwal had turned down the security offered to him by Ghaziabad and Delhi Police.

Kejriwal came out strongly against the attack on the party's Kaushambi office saying the attackers can kill him if that solves the Kashmir issue. He said, "If they think by killing me or Prashant Bhushan, the Kashmir issue will get resolved, then they should tell me the place and date when they want to kill me and I'll go."

The group involved in the attack reportedly identified themselves as the Hindu Raksha Dal, and said they had attacked the office on account of Bhushan's statements. "We attacked AAP's office because of Prashant Bhushan's remarks on Kashmir," NDTV quoted a senior functionary of the group as saying.

The Hindu Raksha Dal activists broke flower pots kept outside AAP's office and tore party posters. Some glass doors were also smashed in the attack.

"We today staged a protest against AAP's stand on Kashmir. AAP's leader Prashant Bhushan's remark on Kashmir is very sad for Hindus due to which we have staged protest outside party office," said Pinky Choudhary, national convenor, Hindu Raksha Dal.


Morten Karlsen Sorby is the new Uninor CEO: All you need to know

Norwegian firm Telenor Wednesday appointed its strategy and regulatory affairs head Morten Karlsen Sorby as the new Chief Executive Officer of its Indian telecom arm Uninor effective immediately.

"Morten's vast experience from the global mobile industry and solid leadership skills will inject new energy and further insights into the already empowered Uninor team," Jon Fredrik Baksaas, President and Chief Executive Officer of Telenor Group, said in a statement.

Telenor holds a 74 percent stake in Telewings Communications, which manages and operates Uninor.

The appointment of the new Uninor CEO comes as the company prepares its strategy for India's spectrum auction, scheduled from February 3. The last date for submitting entries for the auction is January 15.

Telenor holds a 74 percent stake in Telewings Communications, which manages and operates Uninor.  AFP

Telenor holds a 74 percent stake in Telewings Communications, which manages and operates Uninor.
AFP

"The strategy is clear and our model is proven. My job will be to deliver on this strategy alongside the management team and every single Uninor employee. I have actively contributed to the development of our India operations since we first entered in 2008 and now I look forward to joining the remarkable Uninor organisation," Sorby said.

Before his appointment as Uninor CEO, Sorby served as Head of Strategy and Regulatory Affairs in Telenor Group. He has previously been head of Telenor's Norwegian and Nordic mobile and fixed network operations.

Sorby, a state-authorised public accountant in Norway, holds a Master of Science in Business Administration and has qualifications from the International Institute for Management Development in Switzerland.

The nomination of Sorby as CEO of Uninor is subject to regulatory approvals. Sigve Brekke, who took charge as interim CEO after the resignation of Yogesh Malik, will continue as Head of Telenor Group's Asia Operations.

Uninor has over 32 million customers in the country's fastest-growing and most populous telecom circles: UP East, UP West, Bihar, Andhra Pradesh, Maharashtra & Goa and Gujarat.

PTI


Arvind Kejriwal attends first public fuction as CM at NCC camp

New Delhi: Making his first appearance in a public ceremony as Delhi Chief Minister, Arvind Kejriwal today inspected a guard of honour of the National Cadet Corps (NCC) at a function here.

"It's a tradition that Chief Minister is the chief guest at the NCC Republic Day Camp every year and inspects the guard of honour," a defence official said.

Arvind Kejriwal. AFP

Arvind Kejriwal. AFP

The Chief Minister, who was accompanied by his IRS officer wife Sunita, inspected the guard of honour along with defence officials at the Delhi Cantonment.

In his address to over 2,000 cadets, of which 762 were girls, Kejriwal lauded the work done by NCC in "national building" and developing the "character of the youth," and advised students to become good human beings and serve the nation.

"When you ask people what they want to become, they say doctor or engineer. But I would like you to become better human being. One must become a doctor, engineer or take any other profession because it is the means to earn money, but your goal should be to be better human being," the Chief Minister said.

Former NSG Guard and now an AAP MLA from Delhi Cantonment, Surinder Singh, also attended the event.

PTI


Hindu Rakshak Dal chief detained for attack on AAP office

Following a mass attack on the Aam Aadmi Party's office in Kaushambi, the Hindu Rakshak Dal chief Pinky Choudhary has been detained.

A group of 30-40 people attacked the AAP office in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh and vandalised property today in a reprisal for Aam Aadmi Party leader Prashant Bhushan's statement on holding a referendum on keeping the army in Jammu and Kashmir.

A screengrab from the CCTV footage at the AAP office.

A screengrab from the CCTV footage at the AAP office.

CNN-IBN reported that around 40 persons carrying flags came to the AAP office in Kaushambi in Uttar Pradesh and threw stones at the office while shouting slogans. The protest lasted almost 15 to 20 minutes and property outside the office was damaged as the AAP volunteers in the office had locked themselves in the building.

Uttar Pradesh police officials said that they had rushed additional forces there and were in the process of examining CCTV footage to identify those who were involved in vandalism.

They said no one was injured in the attack. SSP Dharmendra Singh said, "We have identified some people. There were some residents of Ghaziabad and the numbers of their cars have been noted. Action against them will be initiated soon."

He said there was no security at the party office but policemen have now been deployed there and at Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal's residence which is just a kilometre away. He said they will again take up the issue of security with Kejriwal and try to convince him about that.

Earlier, Kejriwal had turned down the security offered to him by Ghaziabad and Delhi Police.

Kejriwal came out strongly against the attack on the party's Kaushambi office saying the attackers can kill him if that solves the Kashmir issue. He said, "If they think by killing me or Prashant Bhushan, the Kashmir issue will get resolved, then they should tell me the place and date when they want to kill me and I'll go."

The group involved in the attack reportedly identified themselves as the Hindu Raksha Dal, and said they had attacked the office on account of Bhushan's statements. "We attacked AAP's office because of Prashant Bhushan's remarks on Kashmir," NDTV quoted a senior functionary of the group as saying.

The Hindu Raksha Dal activists broke flower pots kept outside AAP's office and tore party posters. Some glass doors were also smashed in the attack.

"We today staged a protest against AAP's stand on Kashmir. AAP's leader Prashant Bhushan's remark on Kashmir is very sad for Hindus due to which we have staged protest outside party office," said Pinky Choudhary, national convenor, Hindu Raksha Dal.


BJP condemns attack on AAP office: Nirmala Sitharaman

New Delhi: BJP today condemned the attack on Aam Aadmi Party office near here allegedly carried out by some right-wing activists, saying no one has any right to resort to violence.

"We surely condemn the attack on AAP office, because no one has any right to take the law unto their hands. We will never support anyone doing such an act," party spokesperson Nirmala Sitharaman said.

Nirmala Sitharaman. AFP

Nirmala Sitharaman. AFP

She was commenting on an attack on AAP office in Kaushambi in Ghaziabad, on the outskirts of Delhi this morning, apparently to protest against its leader Prashant Bhushan's comment that deployment of army in Jammu and Kashmir should be on the basis of opinion of the people of the state.

Sitharaman at the same time slammed Bhushan for the comments on Kashmir.

"We also should remember Prashant Bhushan's comments on Kashmir, which is an integral part of India. What Prashant Bhushan has said on Kashmir, we condemn that also," she said.

Around 40 activists of Hindu Raksha Dal broke flower pots kept outside the AAP's office and tore party posters. Some glass doors were also smashed in the attack. Police said no one was injured in the attack.

"We today staged a protest against AAP's stand on Kashmir. AAP leader Prashant Bhushan's remark on Kashmir are very sad for Hindus due to which we staged a protest outside the party office," said Pinky Choudhary, national convenor, Hindu Raksha Dal.

PTI


Does AAP’s all-woman commando force spell trouble ahead in Delhi?

When AAP launched its election manifesto ahead of the Delhi Assembly polls, one of the more headline grabbing initiatives outlined in the document (along with free water and cheap electricity) was its innovative and somewhat outlandish concept of a special 'commando' force to protect women in the city.

Women's safety is one of the most talked about issues in Delhi. Historically considered an 'unsafe city' for its women, the issue however was catapulted into the spotlight with the brutal 16 December gangrape. The public anger and outcry that followed the incident is also seen as one of the key issues that ultimately led to the downfall of Kejriwal's predecessor, Sheila Dikshit. With the subject so top of mind in the city so close to elections, it was unsurprising that AAP focused on the issue so closely. However to say that many people were not expecting a commando force is a safe bet.

Reuters

Reuters

The initiative was greeted with some trepidation as soon as it was announced.

"Former bureaucrats and army personnel often have no clue what the needs of women are. The question is what kind of perspective will these Citizen Security Forces have when it comes to women's safety. If it is the dominant, patriarchal values, then it will be of no use," said All India Progressive Women's Association Secretary, Kavita Krishnan in an interview with Firstpost. She also pointed out that the point of armed vigilantes was something that people needed to be concerned about.

Concerns notwithstanding however, AAP has begun setting the foundation for the commando force. At the helm of this effort is Delhi's newly appointed women and child welfare minister Rakhi Birla. According to this report in the Times of India, Birla has said that the initiative will begin with an all women's commando force.

"We are starting with an all-women commando force. Several ex-armymen and martial art instructors have been roped in to train women. Interestingly, more than men, women are coming forward to get trained, which is a positive sign. They will be trained in Taekwondo and then deployed on several stretches at night," she told the newspaper.

Birla has not provided much more information about the commando force, like how they plan to deal with perpetrators of harassment and how women in distress can contact them. And it is this sort of lofty vagueness about the force has fueled concerns that it could rapidly deteriorate into an armed vigilante group operating outside the powers of the law.

As RTI activist Shekhar Singh earlier pointed out to Firstpost, "The Commando forces aspect is bit worrying. The fear is that sometimes these armed forces might well be the worst perpetrators of crimes against women. From a sociological perspective, we've always seen that when there is any kind of violence, the other party always ups the ante and the cycle of violence gets worse".

The idea behind empowering the people to be able to look after themselves and their loved ones is a compelling idea, but has the potential to backfire.

As put across so powerfully by Firstpost columnist Seetha Parthasarathy:

Delhi needs an active and vigilant citizenry; but this should not become an aggressive vigilante mode, which is susceptible to misuse. The initial lot of AAP volunteers may be an idealistic bunch who will not misuse their powers, but can AAP stand guarantee for each and every volunteer, especially those flocking to it in droves after it formed the government?


Does AAP’s all-woman commando force spell trouble ahead in Delhi?

When AAP launched its election manifesto ahead of the Delhi Assembly polls, one of the more headline grabbing initiatives outlined in the document (along with free water and cheap electricity) was its innovative and somewhat outlandish concept of a special 'commando' force to protect women in the city.

Women's safety is one of the most talked about issues in Delhi. Historically considered an 'unsafe city' for its women, the issue however was catapulted into the spotlight with the brutal 16 December gangrape. The public anger and outcry that followed the incident is also seen as one of the key issues that ultimately led to the downfall of Kejriwal's predecessor, Sheila Dikshit. With the subject so top of mind in the city so close to elections, it was unsurprising that AAP focused on the issue so closely. However to say that many people were not expecting a commando force is a safe bet.

Reuters

Reuters

The initiative was greeted with some trepidation as soon as it was announced.

"Former bureaucrats and army personnel often have no clue what the needs of women are. The question is what kind of perspective will these Citizen Security Forces have when it comes to women's safety. If it is the dominant, patriarchal values, then it will be of no use," said All India Progressive Women's Association Secretary, Kavita Krishnan in an interview with Firstpost. She also pointed out that the point of armed vigilantes was something that people needed to be concerned about.

Concerns notwithstanding however, AAP has begun setting the foundation for the commando force. At the helm of this effort is Delhi's newly appointed women and child welfare minister Rakhi Birla. According to this report in the Times of India, Birla has said that the initiative will begin with an all women's commando force.

"We are starting with an all-women commando force. Several ex-armymen and martial art instructors have been roped in to train women. Interestingly, more than men, women are coming forward to get trained, which is a positive sign. They will be trained in Taekwondo and then deployed on several stretches at night," she told the newspaper.

Birla has not provided much more information about the commando force, like how they plan to deal with perpetrators of harassment and how women in distress can contact them. And it is this sort of lofty vagueness about the force has fueled concerns that it could rapidly deteriorate into an armed vigilante group operating outside the powers of the law.

As RTI activist Shekhar Singh earlier pointed out to Firstpost, "The Commando forces aspect is bit worrying. The fear is that sometimes these armed forces might well be the worst perpetrators of crimes against women. From a sociological perspective, we've always seen that when there is any kind of violence, the other party always ups the ante and the cycle of violence gets worse".

The idea behind empowering the people to be able to look after themselves and their loved ones is a compelling idea, but has the potential to backfire.

As put across so powerfully by Firstpost columnist Seetha Parthasarathy:

Delhi needs an active and vigilant citizenry; but this should not become an aggressive vigilante mode, which is susceptible to misuse. The initial lot of AAP volunteers may be an idealistic bunch who will not misuse their powers, but can AAP stand guarantee for each and every volunteer, especially those flocking to it in droves after it formed the government?


Rahul Gandhi to hold rally in Amethi on 10 January

Amethi: Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi will inaugurate nine branches of the State Bank of India and an FM radio station in his constituency on 10 January, when he will also hold a rally here.

Gandhi will inaugurate nine branches of the State Bank of India on January 10 and address the people of his constituency at the Ramlila Maidan, party sources said.

Rahuk Gandhi. PTI

Rahuk Gandhi. PTI

He will also lay the foundation stone of a Rail Neer unit (water manufacturing plant), an FM radio station, besides inaugurating a Railway shopping complex, the sources said.

Gandhi, who will be taking night halt at the Sanjay Gandhi Hospital guest house, will hold a meeting with party workers in Gauriganj the next day to chalk out strategy for the 2014 polls, they said.

Sources said that Rahul is expected to be joined by sister Priyanka Gandhi Vadra on the second and last day of his tour.

Earlier, it was stated that Rahul Gandhi would pay a day's visit to his constituency on 10 Janaury.

On 12 January, a rally of Aam Aadmi Party is scheduled to be held at the same Ramlila Maidan where Kumar Vishwas, who is likely to contest the forthcoming Lok Sabha election from the seat, will take part.

PTI


Rahul Gandhi to hold rally in Amethi on 10 January

Amethi: Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi will inaugurate nine branches of the State Bank of India and an FM radio station in his constituency on 10 January, when he will also hold a rally here.

Gandhi will inaugurate nine branches of the State Bank of India on January 10 and address the people of his constituency at the Ramlila Maidan, party sources said.

Rahuk Gandhi. PTI

Rahuk Gandhi. PTI

He will also lay the foundation stone of a Rail Neer unit (water manufacturing plant), an FM radio station, besides inaugurating a Railway shopping complex, the sources said.

Gandhi, who will be taking night halt at the Sanjay Gandhi Hospital guest house, will hold a meeting with party workers in Gauriganj the next day to chalk out strategy for the 2014 polls, they said.

Sources said that Rahul is expected to be joined by sister Priyanka Gandhi Vadra on the second and last day of his tour.

Earlier, it was stated that Rahul Gandhi would pay a day's visit to his constituency on 10 Janaury.

On 12 January, a rally of Aam Aadmi Party is scheduled to be held at the same Ramlila Maidan where Kumar Vishwas, who is likely to contest the forthcoming Lok Sabha election from the seat, will take part.

PTI


Does AAP’s all-woman commando force spell trouble ahead in Delhi?

When AAP launched its election manifesto ahead of the Delhi Assembly polls, one of the more headline grabbing initiatives outlined in the document (along with free water and cheap electricity) was its innovative and somewhat outlandish concept of a special 'commando' force to protect women in the city.

Women's safety is one of the most talked about issues in Delhi. Historically considered an 'unsafe city' for its women, the issue however was catapulted into the spotlight with the brutal 16 December gangrape. The public anger and outcry that followed the incident is also seen as one of the key issues that ultimately led to the downfall of Kejriwal's predecessor, Sheila Dikshit. With the subject so top of mind in the city so close to elections, it was unsurprising that AAP focused on the issue so closely. However to say that many people were not expecting a commando force is a safe bet.

Reuters

Reuters

The initiative was greeted with some trepidation as soon as it was announced.

"Former bureaucrats and army personnel often have no clue what the needs of women are. The question is what kind of perspective will these Citizen Security Forces have when it comes to women's safety. If it is the dominant, patriarchal values, then it will be of no use," said All India Progressive Women's Association Secretary, Kavita Krishnan in an interview with Firstpost. She also pointed out that the point of armed vigilantes was something that people needed to be concerned about.

Concerns notwithstanding however, AAP has begun setting the foundation for the commando force. At the helm of this effort is Delhi's newly appointed women and child welfare minister Rakhi Birla. According to this report in the Times of India, Birla has said that the initiative will begin with an all women's commando force.

"We are starting with an all-women commando force. Several ex-armymen and martial art instructors have been roped in to train women. Interestingly, more than men, women are coming forward to get trained, which is a positive sign. They will be trained in Taekwondo and then deployed on several stretches at night," she told the newspaper.

Birla has not provided much more information about the commando force, like how they plan to deal with perpetrators of harassment and how women in distress can contact them. And it is this sort of lofty vagueness about the force has fueled concerns that it could rapidly deteriorate into an armed vigilante group operating outside the powers of the law.

As RTI activist Shekhar Singh earlier pointed out to Firstpost, "The Commando forces aspect is bit worrying. The fear is that sometimes these armed forces might well be the worst perpetrators of crimes against women. From a sociological perspective, we've always seen that when there is any kind of violence, the other party always ups the ante and the cycle of violence gets worse".

The idea behind empowering the people to be able to look after themselves and their loved ones is a compelling idea, but has the potential to backfire.

As put across so powerfully by Firstpost columnist Seetha Parthasarathy:

Delhi needs an active and vigilant citizenry; but this should not become an aggressive vigilante mode, which is susceptible to misuse. The initial lot of AAP volunteers may be an idealistic bunch who will not misuse their powers, but can AAP stand guarantee for each and every volunteer, especially those flocking to it in droves after it formed the government?